July 13, 2009

Another look at Socialized Medicine

Some people in the USA are clamoring for a Socialized health system much like that of Canada or England despite the fact that many of these patients are traveling to other countries to get health care as they cannot spend the months and years to wait for diagnosis and treatment. Talk about unintended consequences.

Here is one metric that really drives home the disparity:

canada_MRI_CT.jpg

Here is a story of how an MRI correctly diagnosed an ailment that had been incorrectly diagnosed, treated with major surgery and the problem was never fixed. After two years, the English patient finally had an MRI done… In Japan…

From the UK Telegraph:

Man who suffered hiccups for two years diagnosed with cancer
Christopher Sands, who has suffered from a constant bout of the hiccups for more than two years, has been diagnosed with a brain tumour, it has been disclosed.

Mr Sands, of Timberland near Woodhall Spa, Lincolnshire, hiccups persistently every two seconds when his condition is at its worst.

The musician, who is 25, has tried every cure possible, including hypnotherapy, Reiki and yoga.

A backing singer in a band, he has even had an operation to try to cure his hiccups, which at times have prevented him from sleeping and eating properly.

Experts at the Queen's Medical Centre in Nottingham have previously said his condition was down to a damaged valve which had caused an acid reflux condition.

Doctors have managed to create a new valve linking his oesophagus and stomach to try to alleviate the problem.

But Mr Sands now thinks a Japanese doctor has found the cause of the problem - a 12mm tumour at the back of his brain.

The discovery came to light during an MRI scan in Tokyo after Mr Sands was flown out to Japan by a television station to see a hiccup specialist.

Baby Jebus — I am not a Doctor but I have had a bunch of biology in college and even I can tell you that there can be multiple causes for a given symptom. If there is something reflexive like a hiccup, it can be neurological or it can be a physical irritation.

If I were attending this person, I would stuff him to the gills with Prilosec for a week or two to eliminate any chance of GERD and then take a look at the brain.

I found another article dated from March of this year; same poor soul, same Fscking Hiccups (which started in February 2007), same brain tumor. He was being admitted into surgery soon after the article's publication.

Talk about incompetent diagnosis. There is no mention of what television station sponsored Mr. Sand's trip.

Take the soul of the Department of Motor Vehicles with the efficiency of Amtrak and the speed of the Post Office and you tell me that you want the same people handling your Medical care?

Posted by DaveH at July 13, 2009 08:07 PM | TrackBack
Comments

As a physician chronic hiccoughs that are present more than not or with other symptoms is almost always, to me a bad sign of something more insidious going on. As you say neurologically there can be something in the brain or along the vagal nerve, and phrenic tracts causing it, to even tumours under the diaphragm. I have seen heart disease, heart attacks, splenic ruptures, liver abcesses and tumour, lung tumours, pneumonia, esophageal and medistinal tumours, neck abcesses, aneurysms, all these things causing hiccoughs.

I'm not saying to go the the ER every time you have a hiccup, but with other symptoms or unrelenting hiccups... there is almost always something at the root of it.

Don't know if it was medical tunnel vision rather than a public system at the root of this, but I do note your chart from the fraser institute. There is no doubt that US outcomes for cancers, strokes are better than Canadian ones.

Got linked here from http://hallsofmacadamia.blogspot.com/

Posted by: langmann at July 15, 2009 09:05 PM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?